This post was produced in partnership with Husky Liners.
If you search for truck floor liners, WeatherTech is probably the first result you get, but it’s not the toughest one out there. An independent lab ran WeatherTech’s FloorLiner head to head against Husky Liners’ Weatherbeater, and the Weatherbeater came out 78% more durable. It cleaned faster and tested softer underfoot too. AmericanTrucks also tested the mats and reported that Husky’s material can hold up to gasoline and battery acid.
On top of that, it’s about 30% cheaper, starting at a hair shy of $70.
Why it held up
Weatherbeaters are made from ProGard, Husky’s own rubber formula, and it doesn’t crack, curl or wear out. It stays tough and flexible in extreme temperatures, and extreme temperatures are what kill floor liners.
Liners tend to go stiff in January, because they’re made of cheap materials (like PVC and some rubber blends), so they lock into rigid state on the molecular level. The result is a curl in the corners that stops giving you a good seal. Worse still, this happens right when your footwell is packed with slush and road salt, and now it’s getting all over your carpet.
Liners also tend to get soft in August, after a day baking in a closed car, so they’ll permanently dent where you rest your heel while you’re driving. ProGaard, however, holds up to cold and heat, maintaining both hardness and flexibility year round.
A fit you can’t slide around
Husky laser-measures every set for one specific vehicle, so the liner actually follows the shape of your footwell to give you a good seal. It also has a raised lip that goes all the way around the edge and holds whatever you tracked in before it gets to the carpet.
A reporter named Dan Russo ran the Weatherbeater against WeatherTech’s DigitalFit liners in a Subaru Outback and found it sat nearly seamlessly in both the front and rear footwells. Underneath there are hundreds of StayPut nibs that grip the carpet and work with your car’s factory retention hooks, so the liner stays where you put it, instead of creeping forward into the pedals.
Cleanup is a hose and five minutes
Mud, water and road grime come off the ProGard surface fast. Pop the liner out, hose it down, drop it back in.
It doesn’t stain either. In American Truck’s field test, Husky’s cargo liner took spilled soda and gasoline without marking. Spill gasoline on a WeatherTech liner and you’re outside its warranty, which doesn’t cover chemical contamination.
What you’re actually paying for
Install is tool-free and takes under 15 minutes, with no trimming, no cutting, and nothing you need to modify.
Husky engineers, tests and builds these in the U.S.A., and there’s a U.S.-based support team behind them. WeatherTech guarantees its floor liners for three years from the date of purchase, but every Husky set comes with a limited lifetime warranty to the original purchaser against breakage or tearing in normal use. They’re also free from latex, PVC, cadmium and lead, so you’ll won’t have to worry about exposing your children to harmful materials.
Factory carpet doesn’t come back once road salt and spilled coffee are down in it, so don’t let that happen and use a liner to keep your car protected from everything you and the elements can throw at it.
Independent laboratory testing conducted on or before September 2024; hardness and flexibility tests used MY2018 Ford F-150 liners. Price comparison based on Weatherbeater MAP vs. WeatherTech FloorLiner MAP. WeatherTech is a registered trademark of MacNeil IP LLC.

























